Showing posts with label 2*. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2*. Show all posts

25.3.15

White Bird in a Blizzard (2014) review

Shailene Woodley might only be twenty-three years old, yet she has already given a series of truly amazing performances. It feels like she always brings a part of herself into her characters, no matter how different each time they may be. And her role in White Bird in a Blizzard is not an exception. To be precise, Woodley’s performance is the best thing Gregg Araki’s film has to offer, even though her character is not as memorable as other roles she has played. Besides the talented actress, however, the film proves to be rather weak.

It would be considerably interesting to watch a film which never reveals in what direction it’s going to move next, as long as the film itself knows! Unfortunately, White Bird in a Blizzard feels disoriented: it is not the atmospheric thriller it sometimes tries to be, nor does it use very effectively the element of mystery as a disguise for a coming-of-age drama. The script never manages to make Woodley’s character likeable enough for us to actually care for her, while the finale seems to mostly focus on the mystery side of the story rather than the drama, unlike the rest of the film. The biggest mistake, however, Araki makes is that he chooses to conclude the film with an epilogue which explains -in a far more straightforward way than expected (and needed)- everything that could have remained subtly hinted. And it feels like a letdown, since it was the film’s subtlety that made it interesting in the first place.


(2 out of 5 spinning tops)

14.3.15

Chappie (2015) review

Neil Blomkamp, director of District 9 and Elysium recently apologized for the latter, admitting he had relied too much on its appealing concept and neglected to pay the same attention to a satisfactory screenplay. This statement sounds sincere on one hand, but we would appreciate it more if it meant that Blomkamp has learned from his mistakes. Unfortunately, everything he accuses his previous film for can be used to describe his new one as well…

Chappie is, precisely, a promising idea that would need a much more powerful script in order to be effective. This idea is the creation of a form of artificial intelligence (Chappie) that needs to discover the world from the beginning, in a process that resembles a child’s upbringing. As a concept, it contains an intrinsic humane element, as well as the potential for substantial parallelisms with man himself and the formation of his perception of the world. But most of all, it shows that Blomkamp can still demonstrate a sense of filmmaking creativity: he consciously tries to follow the rules of different genres simultaneously, creating a violent, R-rated… “family” film, with no intention of compromising by subjugating one genre to the other.

As expected, unfortunately, this is exactly what the South-African director stumbles upon. He creates a film that doesn’t really know what kind of film it wants to be. The violent action often gives its place to a humane approach and the latter to the lighthearted humour, with the film being disorientated and almost never truly functional. Moreover, the music composed by Hans Zimmer, despite being otherwise interesting, often seems to force the transition from one tone to the other, thus only making it clumsier. Chappie’s biggest flaw, however, is its script’s incapability to convince about almost anything that happens throughout the film. From the criminals’ transformations into either tender parental figures or repentant heroes to the naively humanized robot Chappie, the film’s concept feels annoyingly rough. Also, some details like the battery sign on Chappie’s chest and the obvious product placements cannot but make things worse. As a result, the sentimental elements seem melodramatic and the action never feels exciting, with the humour being the only actually amusing thing left, although it tonally confuses the film even more.

It is worth mentioning that here, apart from certain hints about religion, the social subtext of Blomkamp’s previous works is absent. Lastly, Yolandi Visser and Ninja, members of South-African rap group Die Antwoord, star in the film as themselves for some reason –and some of their songs are included in the soundtrack. Ninja is at times enjoyably comical, whereas Yolandi Visser should have given a considerably stronger performance for her poorly written character to feel engaging.


Chappie has undoubtedly good intentions but it would need a more elaborate screenplay in order to be sufficiently solid and convincing. Blomkamp misses a second chance (after decent, but not memorable Elysium) to live up to the triumph of District 9, only this time, his sci-fi vision seems worryingly ‘blurred’…


(2 out of 5 spinning tops)